Vol. SI - 2 (2026)

					View Vol. SI - 2 (2026)
Published: 2026-11-06

Full Issue

PROCEDURAL LAW

  • PROCEDURAL LAW

    PRACTICAL PROBLEMS IN THE INITIATION OF PUBLIC CRIMINAL PROSECUTION

    Gagik Ghazinyan, Gevorg Baghdasaryan
    View PDF
    Abstract

     

    The article addresses the issues surrounding the grounds for initiating criminal prosecution, the renewal of criminal prosecution, and the investigator’s involvement in the initiation of criminal prosecution.

    Drawing on theoretical interpretations of the grounds for initiating criminal prosecution, comparative international and historical experience, and a systematic analysis of the relevant legal provisions, the authors demonstrate that initiating criminal prosecution against a person requires a preliminary hypothesis, grounded in evidence and capable of being formulated in procedural terms, that the person committed an offence. At the same time, the authors demonstrate that it is not possible to establish a categorical threshold for initiating criminal prosecution. Accordingly, the practice of initiating criminal prosecution discretionarily, sometimes prematurely and sometimes belatedly, can be addressed only through legal reasoning on the part of law-enforcement authorities grounded in the principle of a balanced protection of public and private interests.

    The authors take the view that the legislature has impermissibly treated the revocation not only of a decision to terminate criminal prosecution, but also of a decision not to initiate criminal prosecution, as a form of renewing criminal prosecution, making it mandatory, in the latter case, to confer accused status on the person. The authors argue that the revocation of a decision not to initiate criminal prosecution cannot, in itself, automatically constitute grounds for initiating criminal prosecution against a person and that, in such a case, the question of criminal prosecution should be resolved in accordance with the general procedure prescribed by the Code, based on an assessment of the facts indicating that an offence has been committed.

    According to the authors, the procedural framework governing the initiation of criminal prosecution, together with its overly restrictive interpretations, has excluded the investigator from participating in determining whether criminal prosecution should be initiated, disregarding the fact that the investigator is the sole procedural actor who establishes and directly perceives the facts constituting the grounds for initiating criminal prosecution. In the authors’ view, the decision to initiate criminal prosecution should be adopted by the investigator and acquire legal effect upon approval by the prosecutor, thereby ensuring, on the one hand, the investigator’s participation in this process, which is pivotal to the pre-trial investigation, and, on the other hand, preserving the exclusivity of the prosecution service’s authority to initiate criminal prosecution.

    References
  • PROCEDURAL LAW

    DISAGREEMENTS BETWEEN THE PUBLIC PARTICIPANTS IN THE PROCEEDINGS IN THE PROCEDURE FOR INITIATING CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AND THE INITIATION OF CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AS A SEPARATE, EXCLUSIVE POWER OF THE INVESTIGATOR

    Samvel Dilbandyan, Hrayr Hovakimyan
    View PDF
    Abstract

    The article examines the problems concerning the relationship between the competences of the public participants in the proceedings and the disagreements arising between them in the procedure for initiating criminal proceedings. Considering the initiation of criminal proceedings as a separate and exclusive procedural power vested in the investigator, the author first addresses the legal significance of the transition from the model of “instituting a criminal case” to the mechanism of “initiating criminal proceedings” and the lawful prerequisites for the commencement of proceedings.

    Subsequently, on the basis of a combined analysis of the legal nature of the prosecutor’s report and their instruction to initiate criminal proceedings, the author substantiates that a prosecutorial instruction, as a means of supervisory influence, cannot independently replace the occasion prescribed by law for initiating criminal proceedings. In this context, it is proposed to establish legislatively that such an instruction must comply with the requirements prescribed for a prosecutor’s report or be accompanied by the corresponding report.

    The procedural procedure applicable when an investigator discovers indications of another alleged crime during the preliminary investigation is discussed separately. Through an analysis of the relationship between Articles 41, 173 and 177 of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Republic of Armenia (hereinafter referred to as the Code), the author identifies the normative uncertainty between the power to initiate new proceedings immediately and the requirements for submitting a report of a crime. It is proposed to recognise such discovery as an independent lawful occasion for initiating criminal proceedings. At the same time, it is substantiated that, until the legislative elimination of the aforementioned uncertainty, following any of the possible interpretations of the competing regulations cannot, in itself, constitute a sufficient basis for instituting disciplinary proceedings against the investigator.

     

     

    References
  • PROCEDURAL LAW

    THE ROLE OF PRECEDENT DECISIONS OF THE COURT OF CASSATION IN SHAPING JUDICIAL GUARANTEES OF THE RIGHT TO LIBERTY: A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS

    Hamlet Asatryan
    View PDF
    Abstract

    The article analyses precedent decisions of the Court of Cassation of the Republic of Armenia adopted in 2005–2011 that established key judicial guarantees of the right to liberty and the right to a fair trial: recognition of the “criminal” nature of administrative detention, the availability of bail regardless of the gravity of the charge, the standards of due diligence and reasoning in extending pre-trial detention, the requirement to bring a wanted person promptly before a judge, and the “reasonable suspicion” standard. Using comparative and historical legal methods, the article examines the state of judicial practice before and after each decision. It argues that the positions examined followed a common path — from a European Convention standard to a domestic precedent and then to legislative regulation — and that judicial precedent functions in the Armenian legal system as an independent instrument of legal development. Particular emphasis is placed on the role of Davit Avetisyan in shaping this case law.

    References
  • PROCEDURAL LAW

    PECULIARITIES OF INITIATING CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS IN CASES RELATED TO MONEY LAUNDERING CASES

    Davit Melkonyan, Milena Hayrapetyan
    View PDF
    Abstract

    The purpose of this article is to analyze certain peculiarities related to the initiation of criminal proceedings in money laundering cases.

    The article examines such issues as the legal necessity for, and possible legal consequences of, the Financial Monitoring Center (hereinafter also referred to as the FMC) of the Central Bank of the Republic of Armenia sending a notification to a public participant in the proceedings, as well as the necessity of initiating new criminal proceedings in relation to the criminal offense of money laundering where criminal proceedings have already been initiated in relation to the predicate offense preceding the money laundering. Relevant research has been conducted with respect to these issues, on the basis of which practical proposals are presented.

    Emphasizing the role of the FMC in combating money laundering, the article aims to prevent, as far as possible, the circumvention of statutory requirements by public participants in the proceedings within the framework of legal relations arising from the exercise of the FMC’s powers. In addition, it is important to ensure the implementation of the principle of legal certainty and the realization of a legitimate public purpose within these legal relations. The article also puts forward practical proposals aimed at achieving these objectives.

    The research conducted for this article has identified legislative gaps and resulted in proposals aimed at addressing them.

    In addition, the article seeks to reiterate the necessity of initiating new criminal proceedings in money laundering cases where the grounds and conditions for initiating criminal proceedings exist.

    To this end, the article puts forward proposals whose adoption would contribute to addressing legislative gaps concerning the initiation of criminal proceedings in money laundering cases.

    The approaches presented in the article may be of interest to legal professionals involved in legislative drafting, as well as to law enforcement officers and judges.

    References
  • PROCEDURAL LAW

    PROSPECTS FOR ENHANCING OPERATIONAL-INVESTIGATIVE ACTIVITIES IN LIGHT OF THE CASE LAW OF THE COURT OF CASSATION OF THE REPUBLIC OF ARMENIA

    Vahe Yengibaryan
    View PDF
    Abstract

    The article examines the case law of the Court of Cassation of the Republic of Armenia concerning operational-investigative (operational-search) measures conducted on the basis of judicial authorization. Its purpose is to analyse and synthesise the fundamental principles, approaches and legal positions derived from the precedent-setting decisions of the Court of Cassation that may prove useful and effective in the conduct of operational-investigative activities. Drawing on the Constitution of the Republic of Armenia, the RA Law “On Operational-Search Activities”, the RA Code of Criminal Procedure and the case law of the European Court of Human Rights, the author considers judicial review as a key safeguard against arbitrary interference with the right to respect for private life. Particular attention is paid to the enhanced protection of communications between the accused and defence counsel, the two-stage test for challenging judicial decisions authorizing operational-investigative measures, the requirement that the desired result cannot reasonably be achieved by other means, the qualitative rather than quantitative assessment of the materials supporting an application, the requirements applicable to judicial acts authorizing such measures, and the conduct of “covert observation” in places of detention. The study employs the formal-legal and comparative-legal methods, as well as the analysis and synthesis of judicial practice. The author concludes that judicial oversight is a fundamental mechanism for maintaining a proper balance between constitutionally protected interests, and that the legal positions of the Court of Cassation have evolved in accordance with the principle of a reasonable balance between public and private interests.

    References
  • PROCEDURAL LAW

    SELECTED ISSUES CONCERNING THE CONDITIONS FOR THE LAWFULNESS OF APPLYING A PREVENTIVE MEASURE

    Armen Hovhannisyan
    View PDF
    Abstract

    The article is devoted to the examination of selected fundamental issues concerning the conditions for the lawfulness of applying a preventive measure, with particular attention to certain problems related to the assessment of reasonable suspicion and the substantiation of the purposes of preventive measures. The paper argues that reasonable suspicion must be understood as a minimum, yet lawful and objective evidentiary threshold, which cannot be overcome through an obvious circumvention of the law, including by reference to materials whose use for proving the relevant charge is manifestly precluded. In this regard, the article also addresses the relevant positions developed by the Court of Cassation, considering them problematic and debatable from a scholarly perspective.

    The next important thesis of the article concerns the assessment of the purposes of preventive measures. The author demonstrates that the purposes of a preventive measure cannot be assessed in an abstract or mechanical manner. They must be substantiated by individualized facts and examined separately, since each risk has an independent legal content. It is emphasized that facts relied upon to substantiate one risk cannot automatically serve to confirm the existence of another risk.

    Addressing limitation periods, the paper advances the position that, as a rule, the expiry of the limitation period for bringing a person to criminal liability excludes an independent ground for applying detention, except in cases where the accused objects to the termination of prosecution and violates the conditions of an alternative preventive measure applied in respect of him. At the same time, it is argued that the approaching expiry of the limitation period, although it does not in itself preclude the application of a preventive measure, constitutes a significant counterbalancing factor in assessing the degree of risks and may lead to the need to choose a more lenient preventive measure, in light of the requirements of the principle of proportionality.

    References
  • PROCEDURAL LAW

    The Principle of Ne Bis in Idem in Armenia’s New Criminal Procedure Code: European Standards, Domestic Implementation, and Interpretive Risks

    Ani Danielyan
    View PDF
    Abstract

    The prohibition of repeated criminal prosecution or punishment for the same act - traditionally expressed as ne bis in idem - is both a guarantee of fair trial and an institutional rule of finality of criminal prosecution. This article examines the way in which the principle is incorporated into Article 25 of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Republic of Armenia and evaluates whether that provision and its implementation are compatible with Article 4 of Protocol No. 7 to the European Convention on Human Rights and with the relevant case law of the European Court of Human Rights. The article argues that the Armenian rule generally follows the Convention model, but its practical application depends on several interpretive distinctions: the difference between a procedural refusal to initiate prosecution and a merit-based determination of criminal responsibility; the distinction between public and private prosecution; and the treatment of administrative or disciplinary sanctions that are, in Convention terms, criminal in substance. On this basis, the article proposes a structured judicial test for Armenian courts and investigative bodies. The central recommendation is that Article 25 should be interpreted through the combined lenses of finality of the prosecution, substantive identity of facts, autonomous criminal character of the act, and the existence of a sufficiently integrated response where parallel proceedings are permitted.

    References
  • PROCEDURAL LAW

    PROSPECTS OF THE APPLICABILITY OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE IN THE CONTEXT OF THE RIGHT TO DEFENSE

    Lusine Hovhannisyan
    View PDF
    Abstract

    Artificial intelligence has moved from the margins of legal practice to its infrastructure. This article argues that the criminal defense bar should treat AI not as a threat to be resisted but as a tool that must be integrated into the exercise of the right to defense, and that the terms of that integration are set by the defense lawyer’s existing duties rather than by the technology itself. Drawing on the European Convention on Human Rights, the Constitution and legislation of the Republic of Armenia, the Council of Europe Framework Convention on Artificial Intelligence (signed by Armenia in January 2026), recent professional guidance and the case law of 2023–2026, the article identifies three limits on responsible integration: the protection of confidentiality and of the secrecy of the pretrial investigation, illustrated by United States v Heppner; the duty of candor in the face of AI “hallucinations”, now recorded in more than two thousand judicial decisions worldwide; and the equality-of-arms problem raised by opaque AI systems deployed against the accused. It concludes with proposals for procedural reform.

    References