Prohibition of Improper Conduct in a Set of Principles of Criminal Procedure

Authors

  • Samvel Dilbandyan Yerevan State University

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.46991/BYSU:C/2024.15.1.106

Keywords:

criminal proceedings, improper conduct, prohibition of unlawful conduct, abuse of right, duty, publicity, proper proof, European Court, offense, procedural sanction

Abstract

The article focuses on the principle of prohibiting unlawful behavior, which is a new addition to the principles of criminal procedure. It emphasizes the importance of studying this principle as it often occurs that individuals involved in legal proceedings either abuse their rights or fail to fulfill their responsibilities. This can disrupt the normal flow of proceedings and negatively impact the legitimate interests of other participants, such as the right of the victim to receive timely compensation for the crime committed against them. The prohibition of illegal behavior extends beyond the abuse of rights to include the failure to fulfill obligations specified by law.

It is justified to impose negative consequences on individuals who engage in abusive actions during criminal proceedings in order to prevent further misuse of their rights. The assessment of a private participant's actions as an abuse of rights should be based on factual evidence by the governing body conducting the proceedings. However, it is important for the governing body to exercise its powers responsibly and prevent the abuse of discretionary rights, which could unreasonably limit the rights of individuals involved in the proceedings.

Author Biography

Samvel Dilbandyan, Yerevan State University

Doctor of Law, Professor, Head of YSU Chair of Criminal Procedure and
Criminalistics

References

Հայաստանի Հանրապետության քրեական դատավարության նոր օրենսգրքի հայեցակարգային լուծումների, նորարարական մոտեցումների և հիմնական ինստիտուտների մեկնաբանման գործնական ուղեցույց, Երևան, 2022թ․։ (Practical guide to the interpretation of conceptual solutions, innovative approaches and main institutions of the new Criminal Procedure Code of the Republic of Armenia, Yerevan, 2022).

Lawless v. Ireland, 26 мая 2016 appeal no. 332/57.

Witzsch v. Germany, 13.12.2005 appeal no. 41448/98.

Kerechashvili v Ceorgia, 28.04.2009 appeal no. 5667/02.

Rehdk v. the Gzech Republic, 18․05․2004, appeal no. 67208/01.

Chernitsyn v. Russia appeal no. 5964/02.

Mirolubovs and Others v. Latvia, appeal no. 798/5, 15.09.2009։

Ռուսաստանի Դաշնության Գերագույն դատարանի պլենումի 30.06.2015 № 29 <<Դատարանների կողմից քրեական դատավարությունում պաշտպանության իրավունքի իրականացումն ապահովող օրենսդրության կիրառման պրակտիկայի մասին>> որոշումը: (Resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation dated 30.06.2015 No. 29 "On the practice of applying the legislation ensuring the right of defense by courts in criminal proceedings").

ՀՀ քրեական դատավարության օրենսգիրք, 2021թ․։ (RA Criminal Procedure Code).

Братусь С.И. О пределах осуществления гражданских прав //Правоведение. 1967. № 4. (Bratus S.I. On the limits of the exercise of civil rights //Jurisprudence. 1967. No. 4)

Петров A.B. Теория государства и права. Учебное пособие. - Челябинск, 2009. (Petrov A.V. Theory of State and Law. Tutorial. - Chelyabinsk, 2009).

Published

2024-06-06

How to Cite

Dilbandyan, S. (2024). Prohibition of Improper Conduct in a Set of Principles of Criminal Procedure. Bulletin of Yerevan University C: Jurisprudence, 15(1 (40), 106–116. https://doi.org/10.46991/BYSU:C/2024.15.1.106

Issue

Section

CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AND CRIMINOLOGY