Conflict Principle lex voluntaris in Civil Legislation Republic of Armenia

Authors

  • Armen Haykyants Yerevan State Universit

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.46991/BYSU:C/2024.15.1.150

Keywords:

principle, freedom of contract, autonomy of will, foreign law, conflict norm, content of contract, form of contract, contractual relationship, non-contractual relationship

Abstract

Article 3 of the Civil Code of the Republic of Armenia enshrines the principle of autonomy of the will. In the national legal science and also in practice, there are still debatable and often incomplete ideas about the essence and scope of application of the mentioned principle, challenging the extent to which the principle of the autonomy of the will is compatible with the other principle established by Article 3 of the Civil Code of the Republic of Armenia, the freedom of contract,  as well as the sufficiency of the Article 1284 of the Civil Code of the Republic of Armenia, as a tool for the realization of the principle of autonomy of the will, to provide with measures for the full application of the principle .

             In the legal science the principle of autonomy of will was initially formed as a principle aimed at serving the contractual circulation, however in different legal systems, including the Republic of Armenia, the principle of autonomy of will is also applied to extra-contractual relations, and it is not yet fully discussed whether when applied to contractual and extra-contractual relations the principle of the autonomy of the will relies on the same set of tools, or whether, depending on the essence of the target relationship, the set of tools should be different. One can endlessly seek for the answers in legal practice, however, as proven by expertise, the legal practice itself turns to the arsenal of legal science to get the solutions for such cases. There is no doubt that science is the flag bearer in the science-practice cooperation, and it is science that shall provide practice with the keys to solving problems.

Author Biography

Armen Haykyants, Yerevan State Universit

Doctor of Law, Professor, Head of YSU Chair of Civil Law

References

Антонова Е.И. Автономия воли сторон в договорных отношениях между субьектами права разных государств (Autonomy of the will of the parties in contractual relations between subjects of law of different states) //Вестник Чебоксарского кооперативного института. 2008. No 1.։

Гетьман-Павлова И.В. Шарль Дюмулен – основоположник теории автономии воли в международном частном праве (Charles Dumoulin – founder of the theory of autonomy of will in private international law) //https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/sharl-dyumulen-osnovopolozhnik-teorii-avtonomii-voli-v-mezhdunarodnom-chastnom-prave/viewer

Дармокрик В.Ф. Предели принципа атономии воли и право, применимое сторонами при выборе условий сделки в международных договорах (The limits of the principle of atonomy of will and the law applied by the parties when choosing the terms of a transaction in international treaties) //Вестник Саратовской юридической академии No 1(108). 2016․

Загирняк М.Ю. Значение учения о воле Ж.Ж.Руссо и И.Канта для становления филосовско-правовой концепции С.И.Гессена (The significance of the doctrine of the will of J. J. Rousseau and I. Kant for the formation of the philosophical and legal concept of S. I. Hessen) //https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/znachenie-ucheniya-o-vole-zh-zh-russo-i-i-kanta-dlya-stanovleniya-filosofsko-pravovoy-kontseptsii-s-i-gessena

Малкин О.Ю. Правовое регулирование выбора права сторонами договора (Legal regulation of the choice of law by the parties to the contract). М.2008.։

Новикова Т.В. О толковании терминов <<право>> и <<законодательство>> в контексте автономии воли сторон частноправового отношения международного характера (On the interpretation of the terms “law” and “legislation” in the context of the autonomy of the will of the parties to a private law relationship of an international nature) //Вестник Томского государственного уни верситета. Право. 2020. № 37.։

Новикова Т.В. Принцип автономии воли в международном частном праве: Монография (The principle of autonomy of will in private international law: Monograph) . М.РГУП. 2021.

Розенберг М.Г. К вопросу о толковании условий договора в практике МКАС (On the issue of interpretation of contract terms in practice) / М.Г. Правовое регулирование внешней торговли в СССР //под ред. Д.М.Генкина. М.1961.

Толстых В.Л. Международное частное право: коллизионое регулирование (Private International Law: conflict of laws regulation.).СПб. 2004.։

Эрделевский А. Толкование договорa (Interpretation of the agreement) // "Российская юстиция" N 4, апрель 1999 г.։

Beale J.A Treatise on the Conflict of Laws or Private International Law. Vol.I.Part i. Cambrigde, 1916.

Symeonides S.Party Autonomy in Rome 1 and 2 from a Comparative Perspective//Convergence and Divergence in Private International Law - Liber Amicorum Kurt Siehr; ed. by K.Boele-Woelki, T.Einhorn, D.Girsberger, S.Symeonides. 2010.

Published

2024-06-06

How to Cite

Haykyants, A. (2024). Conflict Principle lex voluntaris in Civil Legislation Republic of Armenia. Bulletin of Yerevan University C: Jurisprudence, 15(1 (40), 150–165. https://doi.org/10.46991/BYSU:C/2024.15.1.150

Issue

Section

Civil Law